Are we seeing a backlash against liberalised commercial gambling?

I have seen a couple of signs just recently that the tide might be turning against the establishment assumption that a strong, innovating and widely advertised commercial gambling sector is necessarily a good thing for the UK.

First was the Gambling Commission’s latest newsletter which contains the text of a speech in New York given by the Commission’s Executive Director, Tim Miller, who took up that position last August. This is interesting because it is the clearest acknowledgement that I have yet seen from anyone at the Commission that we might just have got it wrong in terms of the place of gambling in society and that a backlash against a liberalised commercial gambling sector may be underway. He refers to the 2005 Gambling Act as having introduced in Britain ‘one of the most liberal gambling markets in the world’. He believes we may be seeing public attitudes hardening against gambling, as witnessed for example by the decrease that the Commission has recorded in the proportion of people believing that the provision of gambling is fair and can be trusted. That proportion fell from just under half in 2008 to only a third in 2016. The decline in trust of gambling was even greater amongst gamblers than non-gamblers. He spoke interestingly about a possible breakdown in the implied social contract between gambling providers and the general public. If that is happening, he thought it would be pressure groups, politicians and the media who will point this out and be active in forcing change. He also said, ‘A responsible approach to gambling is a partnership – a partnership between both gambler and operator. But my challenge to you today is whether that partnership is being shared fairly? Is there too much expectation on the gambler to be responsible and not enough on the industry? … Are we thinking too much about ‘responsible gamblers’ and not enough about ‘responsible gambling’? These are strong words coming from the Gambling Commission, a pillar of the Gambling Establishment.

Second, coming from a very different direction, were football manager Arsene Wenger’s recent critical comments about gambling. The Arsenal manager has pointed to the hypocrisy of the Football Association banning Burnley player Joey Barton from playing for the next 18 months at a time when the English Premier League has become so heavily dependent on gambling company sponsorship and problem gambling has become such a prevalent problem amongst players. The Financial Times has recently said that, ‘It is clear the Premier League has a gambling problem’. The Football Association has now announced its own enquiry into its relationship with gambling and alcohol companies.

Perhaps the time has come for a root and branch rethink about the role of gambling in Britain. Should we acknowledge that the 2005 Gambling Act, which reset the basic rules about how gambling is provided in this country, went too far? Now that the results of the 2005 legislation are becoming clearer, is the time coming for a major new comprehensive gambling policy review? I recently heard this idea expressed by one of the speakers at a meeting organised by the Public Policy Exchange on The Future of Gambling in the UK held on 11 May in London. Dan Waugh of the Young Gamblers’ Education Trust made the point that it was now 16 years since the last major British government Gambling Review or Royal Commission, which tend to come round roughly every 20 years or so. He’s right about that: there were Royal Commissions in 1933, 1951 and 1978 and the major Gambling Review in 2001 which led to the 2005 Gambling Act. So the next one is almost due!

 

People in this conversation

Comments (1)

  • Pavlos Permalink

    A crackdown by the Gambling Commission, ASA and CMA on misleading ads and offers in online gambling has had the industry in a frenzy in recent months. The plethora of new online casinos launching has meant more competition than ever, and so more "generous" promotions have appeared to attract new customers, but all with increasingly predatory conditions making it impossible for players to withdraw winnings.

    The clampdown laid down strict rules about misleading ads, and it is now obvious how merciless the terms have become over the last decade. In the same way that we are seeing how ludricrous the APRs are on loans advertised on TV, we are now seeing how ridiculous the wagering requirements are on "free bonuses" in online gambling.

    It's no surprise therefore that the "proportion of people believing that the provision of gambling is fair and can be trusted" has fallen. It's time to rebuild trust and transparency in the industry.

    We support fairness and "responsible gambling" in the industry, and by raising awareness about predatory terms and convincing players to boycott operators who don't hold the same values, I believe we can force the industry to shift towards competing on favorable terms rather than dishonest bonuses.

    Regards,
    Pavlos
    NoWagering

    about 3 weeks ago

Leave your comments

Guest
Friday, November 24, 2017
0 characters
terms and condition.

Why Gambling Watch UK is needed?

Opportunities for gambling in Britain have increased very considerably in the last 20 years and were given further encouragement with the passing of the 2005 Gambling Act. The latest British Gambling Prevalence Survey, carried out in 2009/10, found that between one third and one half a million British adults experienced a gambling problem in the previous 12 months.
read more

Our Mission and Aims

Gambling Watch UK is an organisation, independent of Government or the gambling industry, which exists to question the present policy of support for the expansion of gambling in the UK and to propose alternative policies which would have the effect of preventing such expansion, which it's members believe is harmful from a public health perspective ...
read more

Support Gambling Watch UK

We believe there is overwhelming support for the view that there are already too many opportunities for gambling and that this is bad for individual, family and community health, but our voices need to be heard if we are to influence public policy. If you agree with the Mission and Aims of Gambling Watch UK, then please register your support.
support us